voyages labs🦉 Philosophy Club Türkçe
Comparative

Comparative

comparison · 24 questions (easy 0 · medium 2 · hard 22)

Questions that set thinkers side by side: the links and differences running from Descartes's doubt to Kant's critique, from Hegel's dialectic to Lukács's reification, and from Freud's unconscious to Nietzsche's critique of values.

Take 10 questions on this topic →Quiz on all topics

Questions and explained answers

There are 24 questions on this topic; 10 examples with explanations are shown here. Take the quiz for all of them.

Medium

  1. Who compared Kant to Robespierre, inviting Solomon to compare Hegel to Napoleon?
    1. Lukács
    2. Nietzsche
    3. Freud
    4. Heinrich Heine
    Show answer and explanation

    Correct answer: D) Heinrich Heine

    Kant’s Copernican revolution is often compared to the upheaval in France, but Solomon credits Hegel with consolidating and spreading it, as Napoleon did.

    Source: Solomon, R. C. (1993). “Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit.” In R. C. Solomon & K. M. Higgins (eds.), The Age of German Idealism (Routledge History of Philosophy, Vol. VI), ch. 6. London: Routledge. ↗

  2. What do Solomon’s Hegel and Connerton’s Lukács share?
    1. Ideas and forms of consciousness can be understood only through their historical development
    2. The thing-in-itself is knowable
    3. Isolated individuals alone make history
    4. Ethics rests on individual autonomy
    Show answer and explanation

    Correct answer: A) Ideas and forms of consciousness can be understood only through their historical development

    Solomon credits Hegel with adding the dimension of history to philosophy; Lukács praises Hegel for relocating the subject–object problem in history, though he rejects the World-Spirit standing above it.

    Source: Cross-text comparison (several sources)

Hard

  1. Which of the following is NOT asserted by Descartes?
    1. Even an evil demon cannot deny me the fact that I think
    2. Mind and body are just two forms of one and the same substance
    3. The physical world has no purposiveness in it
    4. Matter is extended stuff and physical objects are matter in motion
    Show answer and explanation

    Correct answer: B) Mind and body are just two forms of one and the same substance

    Descartes is a dualist; Solomon refers to “the familiar Cartesian divisions of mind and body”. The one-substance view belongs to Spinoza, whose pantheism Solomon compares to Hegel’s “we are all one”. C and D come from Reiman.

    Source: Cross-text comparison (several sources)

  2. Kant’s claim that the a priori categories are common to human understanding as such implies that:
    1. We derive the categories from the experiences we share
    2. Human beings can know the world as it really is in itself
    3. Human understanding constitutes the universal ground of all our truth claims
    4. Everybody understands something in some way and should be respected
    Show answer and explanation

    Correct answer: C) Human understanding constitutes the universal ground of all our truth claims

    Bonevac: for Kant, as for Protagoras, man is the measure, and there is one and only one measure: the categories underlying all possible experience. A is wrong because categories are a priori, not derived from experience; B is wrong because things-in-themselves are unknowable.

    Source: Cross-text comparison (several sources)

  3. How does Hegel transform Kant’s “transcendental ego”?
    1. He denies any subject of experience
    2. He turns “consciousness in general” into a literally general, shared consciousness: Spirit
    3. He reduces it to the empirical ego
    4. He places it in a transcendent God
    Show answer and explanation

    Correct answer: B) He turns “consciousness in general” into a literally general, shared consciousness: Spirit

    For Kant the transcendental ego can never be an object, so it cannot be “yours” or “mine”; it is consciousness in general. Hegel takes this literally: the self that pervades and embraces us all is Spirit.

    Source: Cross-text comparison (several sources)

  4. According to Lukács, how do Kant, Hegel and Marx treat the contradictions of philosophy?
    1. Kant: logical contradictions; Hegel: expressions of historical contradictions; Marx: resolvable only by acting in a new way
    2. Kant: historical; Hegel: logical; Marx: psychological
    3. All three: resolvable by clearer conceptual analysis
    4. None of them saw contradictions
    Show answer and explanation

    Correct answer: A) Kant: logical contradictions; Hegel: expressions of historical contradictions; Marx: resolvable only by acting in a new way

    The contradictions express the incoherence of a whole way of social life, so thinking more clearly is not enough. Any purely reflective philosophy exists apart from history; the resolution lies in revolutionary practice.

    Source: Cross-text comparison (several sources)

  5. Reiman finds Descartes’s proof of God circular; Hegel finds Kant’s critique of knowledge circular. What do the two criticisms share?
    1. Both say reason cannot be checked or justified from outside, because the check already uses and trusts reason
    2. Both reject the existence of God
    3. Both defend the evil demon
    4. Both claim the senses are infallible
    Show answer and explanation

    Correct answer: A) Both say reason cannot be checked or justified from outside, because the check already uses and trusts reason

    Reiman: no basis for trusting reason avoids presupposing that trust. Hegel: examining the tool of knowledge is already using the tool (learning to swim before entering the water). Useful for comparison questions across texts.

    Source: Cross-text comparison (several sources)

  6. Kant asserted that:
    1. Knowledge comes from applying correct methods of thinking to reach clear and distinct ideas
    2. The totality of existence is divided into the phenomenal and the noumenal world
    3. The a priori categories change as historical experience changes
    4. We know objects by going out into the noumenal world and observing them
    Show answer and explanation

    Correct answer: B) The totality of existence is divided into the phenomenal and the noumenal world

    A is Descartes’s method of clear and distinct ideas. C is a historicizing view closer to Hegel and Lukács. D contradicts Kant: the noumenal world is unknowable. Hegel’s project begins precisely by rejecting B.

    Source: Cross-text comparison (several sources)

  7. In Henry’s “positive genealogy”, Freud stands in the line of which philosophers?
    1. Kant, Hegel and Marx
    2. Descartes, Schopenhauer and Nietzsche
    3. Plato, Aristotle and Aquinas
    4. Locke, Berkeley and Hume
    Show answer and explanation

    Correct answer: B) Descartes, Schopenhauer and Nietzsche

    Henry’s book traces the structures of appearance through Descartes, Schopenhauer and Nietzsche before turning to Freud. In his view of desire as endless unhappiness, Freud “once again rejoins Schopenhauer”.

    Source: Cross-text comparison (several sources)

  8. Why does Henry include Descartes in the genealogy of psychoanalysis?
    1. Because Descartes discovered the Oedipus complex
    2. Because Descartes was a physician
    3. Because in the first two Meditations the soul reaches its essence by rejecting every worldly dimension, just as the unconscious refuses ecstatic, worldly appearing
    4. Because Descartes believed in the evil demon as a real being
    Show answer and explanation

    Correct answer: C) Because in the first two Meditations the soul reaches its essence by rejecting every worldly dimension, just as the unconscious refuses ecstatic, worldly appearing

    This links to Reiman’s reading of Descartes: radical doubt suspends the external world. Henry ends the chapter by returning to Descartes’s soul as the “omni-phenomenality” of life.

    Source: Cross-text comparison (several sources)