voyages labs🦉 Philosophy Club Türkçe
Hegel

Hegel

1770–1831 · thinker · 38 questions (easy 19 · medium 10 · hard 9)

Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel is seen as the high point of German idealism. In the Phenomenology of Spirit (1807) he traces how consciousness comes to know itself step by step by working through its contradictions; the master–slave dialectic is the most debated stage of that journey. He reads history as the progress of the consciousness of freedom.

Take 10 questions on this topic →Quiz on all topics

Key ideas

Key concepts

Spirit
The unity of humanity, and of humanity and the world; immanent God.
dialectic
Progress to more adequate forms of thought through conflict.
aufheben
To overcome while preserving and raising to a higher level.
master–slave
Hegel’s parable showing that selfhood arises through recognition.
mutual recognition
A consciousness confirming itself only through another.
unhappy consciousness
Consciousness divided within itself, both worldly and divine.
sense-certainty
Concept-free “this, here, now”; the poorest truth.
Sittlichkeit
Ethics grounded in a community’s shared customs.
Moralität
Kant’s abstract, individual, a priori morality.
absolute knowing
The all-encompassing comprehension of every form of consciousness.
inverted world
Hegel’s reductio of Kant’s noumenon.
teleology
Progress toward an end or goal.
self-consciousness
Consciousness grasping itself as the source of understanding.

Questions and explained answers

There are 38 questions on this topic; 10 examples with explanations are shown here. Take the quiz for all of them.

Easy

  1. Why does Solomon warn against translating Geist as “mind”?
    1. Because “mind” is literally wrong
    2. Because “spirit” has religious meaning and suggests something shared and larger than a person, while “mind” suggests something private
    3. Because Hegel wrote in Latin
    4. Because Geist means only intelligence
    Show answer and explanation

    Correct answer: B) Because “spirit” has religious meaning and suggests something shared and larger than a person, while “mind” suggests something private

    It is not literally incorrect but misleading. We speak of the spirit of a group or nation; Spirit means the ultimate unity of humanity, and of humanity and the world.

    Source: Solomon, R. C. (1993). “Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit.” In R. C. Solomon & K. M. Higgins (eds.), The Age of German Idealism (Routledge History of Philosophy, Vol. VI), ch. 6. London: Routledge. ↗

  2. Hegel’s Spirit is best described as:
    1. A transcendent God outside the world
    2. A God within each separate individual
    3. An immanent God that we all are together
    4. A private mental faculty
    Show answer and explanation

    Correct answer: C) An immanent God that we all are together

    Solomon: not a God within, and certainly not a transcendent God without, but the God who ultimately we are. The point is not “I am God” (Heine’s joke) but that we are all God; Spirit requires a loss of individuality.

    Source: Solomon, R. C. (1993). “Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit.” In R. C. Solomon & K. M. Higgins (eds.), The Age of German Idealism (Routledge History of Philosophy, Vol. VI), ch. 6. London: Routledge. ↗

  3. In the Introduction, which metaphors of knowledge does Hegel reject?
    1. Recollection and the sun of the Good
    2. Knowledge as a tool and as a medium
    3. Mirror and lamp
    4. Building and foundation
    Show answer and explanation

    Correct answer: B) Knowledge as a tool and as a medium

    If knowledge is a tool or a medium, it necessarily distorts reality, so we can never know reality itself; the result is skepticism (Locke and Descartes lead to Hume, and Kant only pursued the metaphor further).

    Source: Solomon, R. C. (1993). “Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit.” In R. C. Solomon & K. M. Higgins (eds.), The Age of German Idealism (Routledge History of Philosophy, Vol. VI), ch. 6. London: Routledge. ↗

  4. Why is “sense-certainty” the poorest truth, though it seems the richest?
    1. Because the senses always lie
    2. Because without concepts it says only “this, here, now”; it claims nothing and so is not knowledge at all
    3. Because it is too conceptual
    4. Because only God has it
    Show answer and explanation

    Correct answer: B) Because without concepts it says only “this, here, now”; it claims nothing and so is not knowledge at all

    Its “infallibility” comes from asserting nothing that could be wrong. Hegel agrees with Kant that there is no knowledge without concepts; knowledge is an active process that relies on universals.

    Source: Solomon, R. C. (1993). “Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit.” In R. C. Solomon & K. M. Higgins (eds.), The Age of German Idealism (Routledge History of Philosophy, Vol. VI), ch. 6. London: Routledge. ↗

  5. What is the point of Hegel’s “inverted world” example?
    1. To describe the real noumenal world
    2. A reductio: if Kant’s noumenon is taken seriously, any nonsense becomes equally intelligible
    3. A theory of electricity
    4. An account of the French Revolution
    Show answer and explanation

    Correct answer: B) A reductio: if Kant’s noumenon is taken seriously, any nonsense becomes equally intelligible

    Either the noumenal world is just like the phenomenal one, or it makes no sense even to suppose it. Hegel concludes that noumena are immanent in phenomena; he also shows the two-world view would undermine Kant’s morality (a crime could be good “in itself”).

    Source: Solomon, R. C. (1993). “Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit.” In R. C. Solomon & K. M. Higgins (eds.), The Age of German Idealism (Routledge History of Philosophy, Vol. VI), ch. 6. London: Routledge. ↗

Medium

  1. What impressed Hegel at Jena in 1806 and shaped the vision of the Phenomenology?
    1. The restoration of the Holy Roman Empire
    2. The success of French revolutionary liberalism under Napoleon, seen as the birth of a new world
    3. A Prussian victory over France
    4. A Lutheran reform of the university
    Show answer and explanation

    Correct answer: B) The success of French revolutionary liberalism under Napoleon, seen as the birth of a new world

    Napoleon ended the 800-year-old Holy Roman Empire at Jena. Hegel saw in this the birth of a new world and announced in the Preface the liberation and unification of the human spirit.

    Source: Solomon, R. C. (1993). “Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit.” In R. C. Solomon & K. M. Higgins (eds.), The Age of German Idealism (Routledge History of Philosophy, Vol. VI), ch. 6. London: Routledge. ↗

  2. “The night in which all cows are black” was Hegel’s sarcastic criticism of:
    1. Kant’s categorical imperative
    2. Schelling’s claim that “we are all one”, asserted without rational demonstration
    3. Hume’s skepticism
    4. Christian asceticism
    Show answer and explanation

    Correct answer: B) Schelling’s claim that “we are all one”, asserted without rational demonstration

    Hegel shares the idea of unity but insists it must be demonstrated through reason, step by step, not by mystical experience or dogmatic insistence. That demonstration is what the Phenomenology tries to provide.

    Source: Solomon, R. C. (1993). “Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit.” In R. C. Solomon & K. M. Higgins (eds.), The Age of German Idealism (Routledge History of Philosophy, Vol. VI), ch. 6. London: Routledge. ↗

  3. What does Hegel mean by comparing Kant to someone learning to swim before getting into the water?
    1. Philosophy should begin with experiments
    2. Examining the faculties of knowledge already uses those faculties, so it is covertly circular
    3. Knowledge is impossible
    4. Kant was right to examine reason first
    Show answer and explanation

    Correct answer: B) Examining the faculties of knowledge already uses those faculties, so it is covertly circular

    One cannot investigate cognition except by cognition. So the critique of knowledge cannot be preliminary; it is itself the development of knowledge, which is why the Phenomenology has a dialectical structure.

    Source: Solomon, R. C. (1993). “Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit.” In R. C. Solomon & K. M. Higgins (eds.), The Age of German Idealism (Routledge History of Philosophy, Vol. VI), ch. 6. London: Routledge. ↗

  4. What kind of religion did Hegel’s early essays favour?
    1. A “natural”, “subjective” folk religion of ritual and social participation, rather than one based on authority
    2. Strict Lutheran theology
    3. Religion as a set of abstract beliefs without practice
    4. No religion at all
    Show answer and explanation

    Correct answer: A) A “natural”, “subjective” folk religion of ritual and social participation, rather than one based on authority

    The early essays held up the folk religion of the ancient Greeks as an alternative to Christianity taught as “objective” theology. Religions, he thought, should belong to the life of a particular people.

    Source: Solomon, R. C. (1993). “Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit.” In R. C. Solomon & K. M. Higgins (eds.), The Age of German Idealism (Routledge History of Philosophy, Vol. VI), ch. 6. London: Routledge. ↗

Hard

  1. Which is NOT something Hegel argues against, according to Solomon?
    1. The intelligibility of skepticism
    2. A thing-in-itself distinct from things as we know them
    3. Splitting experience into incommensurable theoretical and practical realms
    4. The first-person, phenomenological standpoint as the origin of knowledge
    Show answer and explanation

    Correct answer: D) The first-person, phenomenological standpoint as the origin of knowledge

    The first-person standpoint is one of the Kantian themes Hegel continues, along with the unity of knowledge and the a priori necessity of forms of consciousness. A, B and C are what he attacks.

    Source: Solomon, R. C. (1993). “Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit.” In R. C. Solomon & K. M. Higgins (eds.), The Age of German Idealism (Routledge History of Philosophy, Vol. VI), ch. 6. London: Routledge. ↗